Few things on my mind recently.
Now that the Karnataka government is asking its citizens to produce their Ration Card to keep their gas connections. The middle class citizens are up in arms blaming the government for their suffering. ie. they have to stand in long queues. And says that this is all unnecessary. Wait a min, if you have a legal gas connection, why should you care? Oh wait, you got your connection by paying 7000 Rs to the clerk without declaring any proofs right? Thats the concern !
Now the question comes, is it really necessary to give subsidized cooking gas to our middle class citizens? If you tell me that its for the poor. I can assure you that more than half of it goes to the middle and upper middle class families.
Lets look at this math. Consider a middle class family of 4. They may need one cylinder a month. They pay around 400 Rs for the cylinder. Savings due to subsidized pricing = 400 (as actual price for a cylinder of cooking gas is around 800) Now every middle class family own a two -wheeler don’t they? They might spent atleast 1000Rs on Petrol every month. But then petrol is taxed twice over, so that government can recover the loss they make on giving subsidized cooking gas. So the family is paying Rs 500 more for the petrol . Loss = 500 Rs.
In short you aren’t gaining anything from the subsidized cooking gas. So shut up.
I don’t think we have to spend the tax payers money on giving subsidized cooking gas to the middle class.
Note : My kitchen is not government sponsored and the above math can be questioned, revisited and considered wrong.
2. Oh ! The businessmen are corrupt. They don’t pay tax.
So I was having lunch with my colleague the other day and was talking about taxation in general when he said “The business people cheat. They show fake sales, bills and get away. They don’t pay tax legally”
I knew where this was going. He was cribbing about the tax he has to pay and that goverment is eating away his money. (which I have also cribbed about in one of my older posts).
“How much rent do you pay?” I asked him.
“9000” he said.
“How much HRA do you get” I asked
“13000” he said.
“How much did you declare for tax benefits?” I asked
“13000, otherwise I would lose tax for 4000Rs a month” He said.
“Exactly. ” I said.
He got my point.
We have corruption deep in our blood. We blame Kalmadi for eating crores. Or discuss about how Priyanka Chopra did not pay tax for 2Cr.
A thief is a thief even if steal just Rs100 or Rs 1cr.
Schools have entrance examinations these days. Not just to the higher classes but even for Kindergarten. I was reading through Canada’s educational system the other day. They too have entrance exams. But the only difference is that they don’t use the entrance examination to reject students. But to evaluate them to understand the level of attention they should be giving to each individual student.
Back in school, when we failed for Math or Science, the teachers used to punish us. Cane us or ask us to write the questions and answers 100 times. If I failed in an exam I considered that as my failure. But now I guess its a collective failure. The teacher has also failed!
4. Points to Ponder.
Okay this is for some of them who has to know few things before they talk about it.
a. No, Christianity did not come to India with the British. They were here much before that. Infact the British was surprised to find a huge Christian population in Southern India. Its believed (with historical evidence) that St Thomas traveled to India (through the Spice Trade Route) and converted some people in Kerala to Christianity 2000 Years back.
b. No, India does not have a National Language.
c. No, middle class is not the majority in India. We try to form the opinion of this country. But we are not the majority.
The (d) point is for my first Team Lead (from my first company). You don’t need to add a point to put an et cetera when you list out things in an email, Sir.
The Taju, So, you mean the etc of the ‘d)’ is not the required in the email.. ?
@Nithin Exactly 😀 haha
A thief is a thief even if steal just Rs100 or Rs 1cr.
Nice Post. Somethings to think and some to just laugh off.
🙂 Yes. Can’t put all this together in twitter. So decided to blog it !
[…] This post was mentioned on Twitter by xylene, xylene. xylene said: Here and there. New post on my blog http://bit.ly/fWVBcc Finally ! […]
Nice post. The killer was d). I still have some of the ‘memorabilia’ from the good ol days. I should get back to it now.
Oh by the way to your point b). Don’t you know? The official language is ‘Indian’. Oh if i had a rupee for every time someone came up to me and said “hey what does that mean in Indian”. Sigh! 😛
haha. Guess only you and Ivan gets what point (d) is 🙂
Yes I have heard of the language called Indian. Guess it sounds similar to the American.
Everyone keeps telling me hindi is our national language..evidently, it is the people who do speak hindi..and why the hell are the speaking hindi in b’lore? was surprised..no kannada anywhere..
the middle class are hypocrites.
I never understood the point even in school. I refused to study tamil, because the teacher expected us to memorize all the poems..and they didn’t teach me the basics right, I couldn’t spell properly even in 10th boards.
the business people get dividend income, for which tax is paid by the company.
most of us buy whatever the govt. says without really looking into it. and those who do are part of the minority within the supposed majority, so we are left to crib to the emptyy cylinders anyway.
Yes the middle class are hypocrites. We always feel that we form the collective opinion of this country.
u know we r moving to bangalore soon!
wow. All the best for the move !
I don’t understand why people keep opposing the existence of a National language… Hindi is not my first language either… I just want to know if you believe in need of a national language. I personally do think it is necessary. We educated people can use English, but what about others? Don’t you think a common language (at least) understood by everyone will help this country to communicate better with each other?
That said, I also think everyone should strongly try to preserve their own language. A Marathi should speak in Marathi to other Marathi person, same goes for all languages..
Also re: to point c), what is majority in India? People below poverty line? I really don’t know..
Why not english (the reason why we have jobs)? Most of them don’t know Hindi anyway.
For(c) the middle class still thinks they are the majority in this country, because they make all the decisions and are active on TV.